The 25 Best College Small Towns in New York

Ranked on The Town Files lifestyle rankings among 707 towns of 2,500–10,000 people in New York. #1 is Sleepy Hollow, NY.

1. 25Cayuga Heights, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   4,114 people · Tompkins County · median home $433,000 · income $166,526 · Jan low 15°F · 63 in snow

2. 24Garden City South, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   4,119 people · Nassau County · median home $740,400 · income $136,164 · Jan low 27°F · 19 in snow

3. 23Albertson, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   5,220 people · Nassau County · median home $803,900 · income $132,955 · Jan low 27°F · 19 in snow

4. 22Lawrence, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   6,809 people · Nassau County · median home $1,623,200 · income $170,000 · Jan low 26°F · 26 in snow

5. 21Walden, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   6,818 people · Orange County · median home $333,500 · income $87,487 · Jan low 16°F · 44 in snow

6. 20Sound Beach, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   7,416 people · Suffolk County · median home $428,700 · income $132,008 · Jan low 26°F · 33 in snow

7. 19Malverne, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   8,560 people · Nassau County · median home $651,100 · income $149,489 · Jan low 26°F · 26 in snow

8. 18Hamburg, New York

   More of a college town than 98% of New York towns

   9,696 people · Erie County · median home $248,600 · income $112,292 · Jan low 16°F · 168 in snow

9. 17East Williston, New York

   More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

   2,645 people · Nassau County · median home $1,068,500 · income $214,750 · Jan low 27°F · 19 in snow

10. 16Montrose, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    2,862 people · Westchester County · median home $422,700 · income $145,320 · Jan low 17°F · 40 in snow

11. 15Brightwaters, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    3,181 people · Suffolk County · median home $768,600 · income $218,000 · Jan low 25°F · 28 in snow

12. 14Manhasset Hills, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    3,649 people · Nassau County · median home $1,057,800 · income $165,536 · Jan low 27°F · 19 in snow

13. 13Hamilton, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    4,107 people · Madison County · median home $264,200 · income $66,750 · Jan low 11°F · 77 in snow

14. 12Glen Head, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    4,837 people · Nassau County · median home $872,000 · income $138,465 · Jan low 27°F · 19 in snow

15. 11University at Buffalo, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    6,798 people · Erie County · median home — · income — · Jan low 19°F · 95 in snow

16. 10Tuckahoe, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    7,084 people · Westchester County · median home $621,300 · income $104,375 · Jan low 23°F · 33 in snow

17. 9West Point, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    7,341 people · Orange County · median home — · income $135,333 · Jan low 21°F · 36 in snow

18. 8Cedarhurst, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    7,374 people · Nassau County · median home $861,900 · income $101,572 · Jan low 26°F · 26 in snow

19. 7Williston Park, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    7,591 people · Nassau County · median home $739,800 · income $156,382 · Jan low 27°F · 19 in snow

20. 6New Square, New York

    More of a college town than 99% of New York towns

    9,679 people · Rockland County · median home $662,400 · income $31,443 · Jan low 23°F · 36 in snow

21. 5Islip Terrace, New York

    More of a college town than 100% of New York towns

    5,323 people · Suffolk County · median home $519,200 · income $155,313 · Jan low 25°F · 32 in snow

22. 4Bronxville, New York

    More of a college town than 100% of New York towns

    6,656 people · Westchester County · median home $1,095,100 · income $215,815 · Jan low 23°F · 33 in snow

23. 3North Patchogue, New York

    More of a college town than 100% of New York towns

    6,751 people · Suffolk County · median home $450,600 · income $107,695 · Jan low 25°F · 32 in snow

24. 2Pelham, New York

    More of a college town than 100% of New York towns

    7,326 people · Westchester County · median home $915,800 · income $184,375 · Jan low 27°F · 33 in snow

25. 1Sleepy Hollow, New York

    More of a college town than 100% of New York towns

    9,986 people · Westchester County · median home $746,800 · income $104,313 · Jan low 23°F · 33 in snow

Price vs ranking

More New York rankings

• The 25 Best Small Towns to Retire in New York
• The 25 Quietest Small Towns in New York
• The 25 Most Affordable Small Towns in New York
• The 25 Best Small Towns for Families in New York
• The 25 Best Quiet, Affordable Small Towns to Retire in New York
• 25 Small Towns in New York With the Cheapest Homes
• 25 Small Towns in New York With the Mildest Winters
• The 25 Most Walkable Small Towns in New York
• 25 Small Towns in New York With the Fewest Tornadoes Since 1950
• The 25 Best Small Towns for First-Time Home Buyers in New York

Same ranking, other places

• The 50 Best College Small Towns in America
• The 25 Best College Small Towns in Pennsylvania
• The 25 Best College Small Towns in Michigan
• The 25 Best College Small Towns in Texas
• The 25 Best College Small Towns in California
• The 25 Best College Small Towns in New Jersey