The Town Files

The 25 Best Small Towns for First-Time Home Buyers in Florida

Ranked on The Town Files lifestyle rankings among 291 towns of 2,500–10,000 people in Florida. #1 is Timber Pines, FL.

Map of the 25 towns12345678910111213141516171819202122232425
Numbers match the ranking.
The 25 Best Small Towns for First-Time Home Buyers in Florida1. Timber Pines100th pct2. Verona Walk100th pct3. Berkshire Lakes100th pct4. Ave Maria99th pct5. Orangetree99th pct6. The Meadows99th pct7. Hypoluxo99th pct8. Fort Pierce South98th pct9. Whitfield98th pct10. Zellwood98th pct11. Roosevelt Gardens98th pct12. Warm Mineral Springs97th pct13. Lely97th pct14. Memphis96th pct15. Indian River Estates96th pct16. Broadview Park95th pct17. Mary Esther95th pct18. High Point95th pct19. Cleveland95th pct20. South Apopka94th pct21. Brookridge94th pct22. Rainbow Lakes Estates94th pct23. Pahokee93rd pct24. Samoset93rd pct25. Ellenton93rd pct
  1. 25Ellenton, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 93% of Florida towns

    4,129 people · Manatee County · median home $281,400 · income $71,402 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  2. 24Samoset, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 93% of Florida towns

    4,146 people · Manatee County · median home $196,800 · income $51,976 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  3. 23Pahokee, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 93% of Florida towns

    5,524 people · Palm Beach County · median home $152,300 · income $53,359 · Jan low 57°F · 0 in snow

  4. 22Rainbow Lakes Estates, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 94% of Florida towns

    3,438 people · Marion County · median home $160,400 · income $50,429 · Jan low 44°F

  5. 21Brookridge, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 94% of Florida towns

    4,658 people · Hernando County · median home $156,600 · income $53,989 · Jan low 44°F · 0 in snow

  6. 20South Apopka, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 94% of Florida towns

    6,803 people · Orange County · median home $280,500 · income $61,151 · Jan low 44°F · 0 in snow

  7. 19Cleveland, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 95% of Florida towns

    3,435 people · Charlotte County · median home $177,800 · income $47,157 · Jan low 51°F · 0 in snow

  8. 18High Point, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 95% of Florida towns

    3,873 people · Hernando County · median home $181,300 · income $49,368 · Jan low 44°F · 0 in snow

  9. 17Mary Esther, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 95% of Florida towns

    3,982 people · Okaloosa County · median home $298,900 · income $76,890 · Jan low 45°F · 0 in snow

  10. 16Broadview Park, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 95% of Florida towns

    7,670 people · Broward County · median home $365,000 · income $73,786 · Jan low 58°F · 0 in snow

  11. 15Indian River Estates, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 96% of Florida towns

    6,584 people · St. Lucie County · median home $280,400 · income $64,063 · Jan low 57°F · 0 in snow

  12. 14Memphis, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 96% of Florida towns

    9,024 people · Manatee County · median home $313,800 · income $74,839 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  13. 13Lely, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 97% of Florida towns

    3,694 people · Collier County · median home $326,100 · income $69,846 · Jan low 56°F · 0 in snow

  14. 12Warm Mineral Springs, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 97% of Florida towns

    5,442 people · Sarasota County · median home $188,300 · income $53,668 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  15. 11Roosevelt Gardens, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 98% of Florida towns

    2,749 people · Broward County · median home $309,600 · income $49,821 · Jan low 58°F · 0 in snow

  16. 10Zellwood, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 98% of Florida towns

    2,758 people · Orange County · median home $184,000 · income $70,278 · Jan low 44°F · 0 in snow

  17. 9Whitfield, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 98% of Florida towns

    2,989 people · Manatee County · median home $470,500 · income $98,348 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  18. 8Fort Pierce South, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 98% of Florida towns

    5,209 people · St. Lucie County · median home $224,100 · income $50,503 · Jan low 53°F · 0 in snow

  19. 7Hypoluxo, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 99% of Florida towns

    2,687 people · Palm Beach County · median home $290,900 · income $78,214 · Jan low 58°F · 0 in snow

  20. 6The Meadows, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 99% of Florida towns

    5,037 people · Sarasota County · median home $382,400 · income $69,774 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  21. 5Orangetree, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 99% of Florida towns

    5,896 people · Collier County · median home $498,600 · income $112,857 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  22. 4Ave Maria, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 99% of Florida towns

    6,242 people · Collier County · median home $459,200 · income $102,949 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  23. 3Berkshire Lakes, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 100% of Florida towns

    2,527 people · Collier County · median home $374,400 · income $85,795 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  24. 2Verona Walk, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 100% of Florida towns

    2,713 people · Collier County · median home $598,000 · income $66,411 · Jan low 52°F · 0 in snow

  25. 1Timber Pines, Florida

    Better for first-time buyers than 100% of Florida towns

    5,163 people · Hernando County · median home $278,200 · income $59,185 · Jan low 44°F · 0 in snow

Price vs ranking

Median home value vs ranking, Florida towns0255075100$31K$262K$494K$726K$957KMedian home valuePercentile
Orange squares are the 25 towns on this list; green dots are other towns on The Town Files in Florida.

More Florida rankings

Same ranking, other places

Methodology. We ranked 291 towns of 2,500–10,000 people in Florida (2020 Census population; towns with 2,500+ people have pages so far). Lifestyle measures are The Town Files lifestyle rankings, built from federal demographic, school, crime and housing data (2025), shown as percentiles. Only towns better than 60% of their peers on this measure qualify, so lists can be shorter than 25. Sources: